If you are thinking about taking money out of your 401(k) before age 59½, the number on the withdrawal form is not the number that lands in your bank account. Several things can stack up at once, and they are easy to miss until tax time. This guide walks through each piece, using a simple Massachusetts example, and lists the exceptions the IRS recognizes.

The three costs that usually stack up

1. Ordinary income tax. Money you contributed pre-tax, and any earnings on it, generally counts as taxable income in the year you take it out. A large withdrawal can also push part of your income into a higher federal bracket.

2. A 10% additional tax. Distributions taken before age 59½ from a 401(k) or similar plan are generally subject to an additional 10% tax on the taxable portion, unless an exception applies.

3. State income tax. Massachusetts taxes most income at a flat 5% rate, so a withdrawal generally adds to your state bill too. Other states differ.

What it can look like: a $20,000 example

This is a simplified illustration, not a prediction. It assumes the full amount is pre-tax money (Roth 401(k) money is treated differently), a 24% federal bracket and the 5% Massachusetts rate. Your numbers will differ.

Item Amount
Withdrawal $20,000
10% additional tax −$2,000
Federal income tax at 24% −$4,800
Massachusetts income tax at 5% −$1,000
Left after taxes about $12,200

In this example, roughly 39% of the withdrawal goes to taxes, and the $20,000 is no longer invested for your retirement. That second part is the cost people tend to underestimate: the money stops compounding, and putting it back is limited. Some distributions can be rolled over within 60 days, but otherwise new contributions are capped each year.

Withholding is not the same as what you owe

Many plans withhold a flat percentage when you take a cash distribution, and for most payments that could be rolled over, federal law requires 20% to be withheld. That amount may be less than your actual tax once the additional 10% tax and your bracket are counted, so some people owe more when they file. The IRS notes that withholding may not cover the 10% tax and that you may need to make estimated tax payments. Setting aside extra cash, or talking to your tax professional before you take the money, can avoid a surprise.

The IRS exceptions to the 10% tax

For 401(k) and similar plans, the IRS lists a number of situations where the additional 10% tax does not apply. An exception removes the 10% tax only. The withdrawal is generally still taxable income. The main ones for most people:

  • Separation from service in or after the year you turn 55. If you leave your job (by choice or not) in the year you turn 55 or later, you can generally take money from that employer's plan without the 10% tax. This does not carry over to an IRA you roll the money into.
  • Total and permanent disability.
  • Terminal illness.
  • Medical expenses above 7.5% of your adjusted gross income.
  • A qualified domestic relations order (QDRO), for money paid to a former spouse or dependent under a divorce order.
  • Substantially equal periodic payments, a rigid schedule of payments after you leave the employer that must generally continue for years.
  • Qualified birth or adoption, up to $5,000.
  • Qualified reservist distributions for certain military reservists called to active duty.
  • IRS levy on the plan.
  • Distributions to a beneficiary or estate after the owner's death.
  • Newer rules for certain domestic abuse victims, personal or family emergency expenses (limited in amount), federally declared disaster losses and some plan emergency savings accounts.

The rules are detailed, the dollar limits and conditions matter, and plans are not required to offer every option. Check with your plan administrator and a tax professional before relying on an exception. The IRS lists the full set in its early distributions topic page.

Hardship withdrawals are not the same as an exception

A hardship withdrawal is a plan feature that lets you take money for an immediate and heavy financial need, such as certain medical bills, tuition or avoiding eviction. Qualifying for one does not automatically waive the 10% tax. Whether the additional tax applies depends on whether one of the exceptions above also fits. We cover the plan-level rules in more detail in our article on hardship withdrawals and 401(k) loans.

Questions to ask before you withdraw

  • Is there a smaller or cheaper source? Cash savings, a home equity line, a payment plan with the biller or a short-term loan may cost less than the combined taxes and the lost retirement savings.
  • Does your plan offer a loan? A 401(k) loan is not a taxable distribution if you repay it on schedule, but it has its own risks, especially if you leave your employer. See our hardship and loan article above.
  • Does an exception apply? Check each one against your facts, including your age and employment status in the year you take the money.
  • Are you leaving your job? If so, a direct rollover to an IRA or your new employer's plan avoids tax and the additional 10% tax on that money. Having a check made out to you can trigger the 20% withholding even if you plan to redeposit it.
  • What does it do to this year's taxes? A large withdrawal can affect things like your tax bracket, Medicare premiums later in life, college financial aid and eligibility for some credits.
  • Have you talked to your tax professional? The right answer depends on your income, filing status and state.

When Boston-area households run into this

Early withdrawals can come up around a job change, a layoff, a home purchase or renovation, a family medical event or a gap between jobs. They are worth planning around rather than reacting to, because the tax cost of the same $20,000 can vary with the year, your income and whether an exception to the 10% tax fits. If you would like a second set of eyes before you decide, we offer a complimentary conversation. Learn more about our Boston office or request a consultation.

Sources

This article is general information, not individualized investment, tax or legal advice. Tax rules change, and how they apply depends on your circumstances. The example is hypothetical, uses assumed rates and is not a prediction of any result. Please consult your tax and legal advisors. Investing involves risk, including possible loss of principal. Radius Wealth Management LLC provides individualized advice only where permitted to do so.